PlayStation 4 versus XBOX ONE - Day One versus Someday




Are you ready for the next generation of game consoles? That is the question of the season here as we're less than two months away from the release of the PS4 and Xbox One. The PlayStation 4 in particular is of note because if you've followed the media coverage over the last 10 months - this launch is posed to go off like fireworks. Sony is projecting sales of 5 million units before the end of 2013 (I'm assuming FY13), which is faster than either Sony or Microsoft's previous launch numbers from the preceding console generation. They've had great media treatment but more importantly they've enamored the hardcore gamers.

Pretty straightforward.


In recent months, and more visibly in the past few weeks - allegations have come out claiming hardware superiority in favor of Sony's PlayStation 4 versus Microsoft's Xbox One. Citing unnamed developers - several sites have reported that the PlayStation 4 is faster by "up to 50%"over the Xbox One. Regardless if this is true or not - the prevailing narrative is that, in some way, Sony's hardware is better than Microsoft's alternative. Response to the Xbox One's bundled Kinect camera has been tepid and these persistent remarks of inferior hardware (however slight), have exacerbated the price differences between the two. Oh you didn't catch that? The Xbox One will be $100 more expensive at retail. The price difference has perhaps caused some, to scrutinize more deeply what each platform has to offer. In particular this has led many to take a harder look at Microsoft's recent DRM debacle and subsequent reversal as well as what it really is they're offering. Both consoles will require their own form of a subscription service to play games online and to extrapolate what those experiences will be, let's look at the current hardware and services to perhaps give us a preview of what's to come.


A glimpse into the future?


Currently Xbox LIVE on the Xbox 360 costs at retail, $60 per year (cheaper online) and allows use of online gaming and streaming apps such as Netflix, Hulu Plus, etc. In other words, everything other than single-player games or offline multiplayer games are behind some sort of paywall. And that's not to say that what's behind that paywall is free either. For example, to be able to use Netflix on your Xbox 360, you must pay for the Netflix and Xbox Live subscriptions - two fees for one serviceConversely, on the PlayStation 3 - online gaming is free and use of apps such as Netflix and Hulu Plus are unblemished by this pay structure. Sony's current subscription service (PlayStation PLUS), costs at retail, $50 per year and grants access to exclusive discounts and free games monthly for the PlayStation 3 and PlayStation Vita. The caveat is that you must be a member in good-standing (still paying for the service) to access your "Instant Game Collection" but once you download any free title - it's tied to your account regardless if you decide to opt out of your membership and re-establish it later on. You don't lose anything.

Few things have changed structurally for the next generation. The Xbox One offering is nearly identical to its predecessor's - nearly everything is behind a paywall. Similarly, the PlayStation 4 offering is identical to the PlayStation 3 albeit online play is behind a paywall. They now both offer the same services (subscription-based online play, access to third-party apps, game DVR), yet Microsoft's are behind a paywall and beyond online play - Sony's are not. (Sony also consistently offers critically well-received games monthly, for free as part of their service.) Doesn't this seem like starkly contrasting approaches? And would anyone be looking as closely if they were more similarly priced?

As it stands, the PlayStation 4 is a supreme value at $399, with a lower cost of ownership and an overabundance of perks. Personally, I will inevitably own both (how could I not?), but at least at launch and until Microsoft reduces their cost of ownership and retail price - I will be thoroughly enjoying the PlayStation 4.

What will you be getting at launch? Post in the comments below or on twitter @techandjunk